September 28th, 2007
What Does ‘American’ Mean?
I read an article in the Times today that got me thinking. It’s a story about the revamping of the US naturalization test that immigrants must take to become citizens. Quoting from the article:
“The redesign of the test … follows years of criticism in which conservatives said the test was too easy and immigrant advocates said it was too hard.
…
“The Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights … said the test included ‘more abstract and irrelevant questions’ that tended to stump hard-working immigrants who had little time to study.
…
“‘People who take this seriously will have a good chance of passing,’ said Gary Gerstle, an professor of American history at Vanderbilt University. ‘Indeed, their knowledge of American history may even exceed the knowledge of millions of American-born citizens.’”
I like immigrants. I believe that on the whole, immigrants are brave, hard-working people who are looking for opportunity and a better life for themselves and their families. Immigrants have always been the backbone of this country and one of its greatest assets. That being said, I’m all for a tough naturalization exam, because I believe that Americans should be expected to know and understand the basic tenets of their country.
But note that I said Americans, not immigrants in the above statement. In fact, I find a tremendous amount of hypocrisy in an exam that only immigrants are expected to take. Isn’t it totally discriminatory to expect those who are born outside these lands to pass an exam that many natural-born citizens would be stumped by? In fact, we celebrate the stupidity of our citizens on shows like the Tonight Show, where Jay Leno goes ‘Jay Walking,’ all the time, while we expect immigrants who haven’t had the benefit of our educational system to answer the same questions we as Americans often can’t. I think we all too often have a disgusting sense of entitlement in this country, and this is just another example of that.
So here is my suggestion: make every American citizen, immigrant or natural-born, take and pass this exam. For those who can’t, well, maybe someone is hiring down in Mexico.
See it you would pass; Take a test of some (admittedly difficult) questions from the US immigration exam.